Why Europe’s Major Stock Exchange Merger Is About to Collapse
The London Stock Exchange has all but ended a planned merger with Deutsche Boerse to create Europe’s biggest stock exchange by ruling out a European antitrust demand, saying it has strong prospects alone.
In a bid to create a European trading powerhouse that would better compete against U.S. rivals making inroads on their home turf, the two exchanges struck a 29 billion euro ($ 30.1 billion) deal just over a year ago.
If the merger fails, it will be the latest in a series of doomed efforts at dealmaking by stock exchanges and the likely breakdown of the latest attempt disappointed investors, with shares in Deutsche Boerse (dboey) tumbling more than 4% in early trading and London Stock Exchange (ldnxf) shares down 3%.
In a highly unusual step, the London Stock Exchange (LSE) on Sunday preempted a European Commission antitrust decision, saying it was unlikely to give clearance for the merger after the London bourse had refused to sell an electronic trading platform in Italy.
A deal would now only be possible if the Commission, which declined to comment, were to change its demands—an outcome that is unlikely given its approach in other mergers.
There had already been four attempts, two public and two informal, to combine the London and Frankfurt bourses during the past decade, while the European Union (EU) blocked a $ 17 billion tie-up between what was then NYSE Euronext and Deutsche Boerse in 2012.
However, while hopes had been high that the plan to create what the head of Deutsche Boerse dubbed a financial bridge between continental Europe and Britain, this had been called into question by Brexit, with German politicians demanding Frankfurt not London be the headquarters of the group because Britain would be leaving the trading bloc.
The question over where the headquarters should be, which would have arisen had EU authorities given the deal a green light, worried LSE executives, two people familiar with the matter said.
Britain’s departure from the EU may isolate London as Europe’s financial center and that had turned the tables in favor of Frankfurt.
But a source close to LSE described the sale of fixed-income trading platform MTS as a key problem because such a move was firmly opposed by Rome.
“MTS has the largest chunk of Italian government bonds which made the Italian authorities wary of a change of ownership.”
Deutsche Boerse said that decision not to sell MTS had been made by the LSE, adding that it expected a decision by the Commission by the end of the month.
The LSE had said in a statement late on Sunday that the Commission had asked it to sell its 60% stake in MTS to satisfy antitrust concerns over the merger of Europe’s two largest market operators.
Calling the request “disproportionate,” the British exchange said it believed that it would struggle to sell MTS and that such a sale would be detrimental to its business.
“Based on the commission’s current position, LSE believes that the Commission is unlikely to provide clearance for the merger,” it said.
The exchanges had already agreed to sell part of LSE’s clearing business, LCH SA, in order to satisfy antitrust requirements.
LSE said the Commission had also raised concerns this month about the impact on the European market landscape of access to bond and repo trading feeds were the two exchanges to merge. LSE said it had offered certain proposals to address this but that the commission had requested they sell all of MTS instead.
MTS is a small part of LSE’s business but it said it was a major platform for trading European government bonds, particularly in Italy, and that it was “systemically important.”
LSE said that such a sale would need regulatory approval from several governments in Europe, and it would be detrimental to its wider Italian business.
“Taking all relevant factors into account, and acting in the best interests of shareholders, the LSE Board today concluded that it could not commit to the divestment of MTS,” the exchange said.
Rules of Discussion on Live Index
2. Member's comments should lead to value addition in forum discussion.
3. If anyone is found making repetitive Explicit/Abusive/Racial comments, his account shall be banned and old posts will be deleted.